The IRS Is Coming for ERC Claims
Billions of dollars in Employee Retention Credits are under review. The IRS has dedicated resources specifically to examine these claims. Here's what every business owner needs to understand.
The IRS Audit Wave Is Here
In September 2023, the IRS announced a moratorium on processing new ERC claims. Why? Because they needed to focus resources on examining the massive backlog of potentially fraudulent or incorrect claims already filed.
The IRS has publicly stated that ERC compliance is a top priority. They've hired additional examiners, developed specialized audit techniques, and are systematically working through claims by risk level.
If you claimed ERC, your claim will likely be examined at some point. The only question is when.
IRS Red Flags
- ⚠ Claims filed by known "ERC mills" or aggressive promoters
- ⚠ Large credit amounts relative to business size
- ⚠ Claims based solely on "supply chain disruption"
- ⚠ Businesses that didn't experience actual revenue decline
- ⚠ Minimal or no documentation to support the claim
IRS Commissioner Statement
"We continue to see aggressive marketing of the Employee Retention Credit that mislead people into claiming credits they don't qualify for. We are increasing our audit work in this area..."
— IRS Commissioner Danny Werfel, 2024
Timeline of IRS Actions
- Sep 2023 Moratorium on new ERC claims
- Dec 2023 Voluntary Disclosure Program launched
- 2024 Increased audit staff and examinations
- 2025-2027 Peak audit activity expected
Penalties Can Exceed the Credit
If the IRS determines your ERC claim was incorrect, you don't just pay back the credit. You pay back the credit plus penalties plus interest. In serious cases, the total can exceed what you originally received.
Penalty Structure
Example Scenario
A $500,000 ERC claim found to be fraudulent could result in $500,000 repayment + $375,000 penalty + $100,000+ interest = $975,000+ total liability
The Math Gets Ugly Fast
This is with the lowest penalty rate. Civil fraud penalties would more than double this amount.
The 5-Year Audit Window
Unlike typical tax returns with a 3-year statute of limitations, ERC claims can be audited for 5 years from the date of filing. For most businesses, this means audits can occur through 2025-2027.
Many of the "ERC mills" and aggressive promoters who filed these claims have already closed their doors. When an audit notice arrives, these businesses are gone — leaving you to defend a claim you may not fully understand.
Why This Matters
-
✗
Your filer may be gone Many ERC promoters have closed or will close before audits peak
-
✗
Documentation may be lost Supporting records need to be preserved for years
-
✗
Memory fades Recalling specifics from 2020-2021 becomes harder each year
-
✗
IRS has time on their side They can take years to build their case before contacting you
Audit Window Timeline
Your Communications May Not Be Protected
When the IRS audits your ERC claim, they can request communications between you and your original filer. If that filer was a CPA, consultant, or ERC promoter (not an attorney), those communications are not protected by privilege.
This means the IRS can see:
Emails
Discussing how the claim was calculated
Worksheets
Showing assumptions and methodology
Notes
About eligibility concerns or questions
Contracts
Showing contingency fee arrangements
When you work with a qualified representative for your defense, your communications about strategy, concerns, and documentation are protected. The IRS cannot compel disclosure of these discussions.
What You Can Do Now
Proactive steps to protect your business before an audit arrives.
Get a Risk Assessment
Understand where your claim stands before the IRS examines it. Identify vulnerabilities and documentation gaps.
Organize Documentation
Gather and preserve all records supporting your eligibility. The IRS will ask for documentation — be ready.
Establish Representation
Have a qualified team ready before an audit notice arrives. Responding quickly and correctly is critical.